Eulogy by Richard Goldberg
Christ & St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church New York, NY
November 18, 2023
First my disclaimer: Those of you who know me know that I’m usually pretty good with words. Not so this time. This time it’s about the woman with whom—up till Tuesday night–I shared a life. 28 years of unimaginable bliss. What I’m going to say today may lack coherence or intelligence. That’s because it’s coming from my heart and not my mind.
It is comforting to know that when I read your emails and texts, heard the phone calls and the words of condolence spoken to me in the elevator or the street, I knew we all knew the same Bobbie. Of course we did. Bobbie Goldberg was unfailingly faithful to being her genuine self, that self so many of us loved.
* * *
I first saw Bobbie in September of 1957. I had been told that there was a new girl in our class at Hartford Public High School, a Barbara Kaminski. That she was somehow already in one of the sororities and was a cheerleader.
“Kaminski,” I thought. “With a Y or and I?”
I can tell from the laughter that many of you know the difference!” Whatever, I found myself peeking around a corner across from the vice-principal’s office where I was told I’d find her. Sure enough, there she was. She looked great, but soo tall and, of course, I wasn’t. Her a cheerleader and me a nerd, and, most important in Hartford Connecticut in 1957: Her a Polish Catholic and me a Jew. I turned back to my home room without saying a word to her. For the next three years we were never more than acquaintances, spending only one semester together in the same class.
After graduation we did not see, talk to or probably think of each other until meeting at our twentieth reunion in 1980. This was the first reunion I’d attended. She was married with kids to the president of our senior class and I was involved in my life in New York City. Nonetheless we chatted and agreed to stay in touch. Letters and occasional phone calls and then, fifteen years later–and again prompted by a class reunion–but now each of us available, we began a yearlong long-distance relationship, culminating in her moving to New York in 1996.
(An aside: At uncounted times in my life have words come from my mouth without my brain’s prior knowledge. Three have mattered overwhelmingly. The first was hearing me ask her to move in with me. The second, again eavesdropping, heard, “Will you marry me?”. Third time marked the end of my five year opposition to traveling to Australia and New Zealand. More of that below.)
Just for a moment imagine me outside my building with flowers under my arm, expecting her to come up the street carrying two suitcases, a raincoat over her shoulder and pictures of the kids under her arm—and then the truck appeared! Later friends would visit, look around and smile. “Hmm,” I heard more than once, ” You finally furnished the place.”
Both our lives had changed. Most importantly, as time passed, she came to realize New York City as the great nurturing ground for her becoming far more than ever before her real self. To watch her grow into the City, to watch them become evermore a harmony thrilled me continuously for the next 27 years.
* * *
Bobbie Goldberg was a woman of love and compassion and joy. She’d never leave a check-out line without a pleasant exchange with the cashier. She’d always carry a few dollar bills in an easily accessible pocket to offer to those on the street in need. Not just the money, but always with time for conversation. (Last Sunday night when David and I were packing her coats and jackets for the coat drive at her church, we found folded dollar bills in a pocket of every single coat.)
- More than one neighbor has told me how much they enjoyed a simple ride in the elevator with her: How she brightened their day or how beautifully she related to their kids—especially at Halloween!)
- Every Superbowl for about ten years we’d join our great friend Luis Rosa then on 121st Street for the game and enormous amounts of food, drink and laughter. She’d struggle up the steps to his 4th floor apartment, resting but never complaining. There she’d be greeted by the all-male rest of the group.“Aw shit,” you’d hear maybe more than once in the laughter. “The Patriots Woman is here again.” She’d flash her Tom Brady shopping bags—filled, of course, with foods that meshed nicely with beer and tequila. Then massive hugs and she’d be ushered to the best seat in the house.
Bobbie was the star of the show!
* * *
Whether we’d walk in Central Park or travel the world or go to the supermarket, it was always exciting with Bobbie. Every trip, no matter how theoretically trivial, would always be filled with opportunities for participating in the world. She was a wonderful companion in China, Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia, India, Nepal, Egypt, Western Europe, Ireland, Canada—we saw a lot together. In Bhutan she’d chat with storekeepers just as she did in New York. She’d ask if they had pictures of their children, and they did. And then she’d showed them pictures of her children!
The best though, Bobbie’s dream trip, a month in Australia and New Zealand. After 15 years of resisting, I finally caved in to that unnamed voice-manipulator for ;what turned out to be one of the best experiences we’ve shared. I still treasure the image of her holding a koala.
For all of that, the greatest experience we shared was without question, our everyday life.
- Walks in the neighborhood—a neighborhood that included Central Park and Riverside Park and the American Museum of Natural History among other delights. Over time the walks became shorter, so our viewing became more detailed and discussed.
- The Crab Shanty (a train and two buses away) on City Island in The Bronx was the go-to spot for birthdays and anniversaries. In later years Uber (courtesy of son David) would bring us home.
- Whether it was Shadow, Kitty-Kitty, Tee-Fee or any of the others (When she moved in she brought Kitty-Kitty and two dogs with her.)
- She loved (and got me to love) the UCONN Women’s Basketball team and, eventually, the New York Liberty. We shared delight in watching women’s soccer.
- Monthly for 11 years we’d travel to Sideshow Goshko at the KGB Bar for storytelling. There we’d find a note writ large on a front-and-center table, “Reserved for Bobbie and Richard.”
- HD operas where we could see facial expressions and read subtitles.
- Playing Wordle.
- Together doing the New York Times crosswords Wednesday through Sunday.
- 4 pm chess, cocktails and popcorn. The last time we played she won two out of three.
- Did I mention jigsaw puzzles of the 1500 piece variety?
- And cooking. Despite my having worked as a short-order cook and having preparing my own meals for decades, the best I could do with her was as sous chef and grill cook.
- And “The Look!” Ask her kids about this one.
- Boy, did she love ice cream!
We shared friends and families while maintaining substantial interests of our own. Hers were painting, collecting and improving recipes (after testing them on me,) cooking, canasta and knitting. Solitaire and Texas Hold ‘Um on the internet. Most of all, though, her kids. Phone calls and texts and FaceTime and visits all the time. Meanwhile I listened to jazz, rode a bike and took pictures.
* * *
The last night we spent together was the night before her death. We went down to the Astor Theater to see Blue Man Group. She’d seen it decades ago but resisted spoilers. (And you wanna know why I love her?). Of course, we were both knocked out.
When it over we found a quiet restaurant/bar for a drink or two. It was late, just three of us at the bar. Number three was at the far end behind his phone. Bobbie and the bartender immediately got into a spirited discussion of things drinkable. After a while, the waitress and even our one fellow customer came over to join in on the Bobbie-centered conversation.
As so often usual laughter dominated.
When we closed the place, we could have taken an Uber uptown. Not Bobbie. Not tonight! Bobbie had decided it’d be more fun and revealing of our city to take a coupla busses. She was ready to see the city after midnight through big bus windows, her head on my shoulder. How pretty the city was. How happy she was. How happy we were!
* * *
Bobbie believed that when she died, she’d be reunited with her parents and brothers Andy and Ron, those she lost here on earth. Her belief was so strong and utterly heartfelt that, I am quite sure, it has been realized.
May she rest in joy!